A surge in population indeed and obviously makes for a surge in the need for clothes and food etc but the quantity strain on housing, cars, hospitals, doctors, coaches, wages etc us far more con than the pro immigrant needs

do these people not realize that if an immigrant pays ie 15% of his income on tax he gets to keep a whopping 85% of the income for himself.
that is money the country is passing over to someone who was not sucking that money before.

if 1 million people get into the USA as immigrants then 1 million more people take from the US coffers and I don’t give a rats behind about them giving back 15%.

most of the other 85% will probably be leaving the USA and arriving in the bank accounts of wife and parents back in mexico or europe

the notion that a huge increase in people makes for more economy is a delusion and far left joke

If they aren’t motivated, that’s your fault. They have spent a lot of time and money on education and your company is enticing the flow of skilled labor into the country, continually devaluing the salaries they were promised while studying. Of coarse you’ve sabotaged their motivation out of the gate.

If a job is worth $75,000 a year when only 100 students are graduating and capable of getting the job, then if you bring over 100 immigrants who are primed and ready to accept less and they compete with the existing foray of new recruits then the job automatically gets devalued to $35,000 a year. And you, the employer will become addicted to the idea and are oblivious to the ramifications, including ones you’ve mentioned yourself but have failed to pinpoint the actual reason for. “On average they are much more motivated”, those are your words, and they imply the effects of a problem you helped perpetuate. Good luck finding loyal workers in the future.

Outsourcing and Insourcing do certainly devalue salaries. It’s the controlling of the supply and demand of skilled labor. When the supply is high salaries go down, and at that point, even if the demand goes up, entry level salaries have already crashed and the demand is only being fought over for senior level workers who now aren’t making nearly what they should be.

Importing skilled labor that comes from foreign middle class money is not our history. Our history is give us your tired, your poor and your hungry and huddled masses, not -give us your middle class strangers who are willing to undercut our own children’s futures. If it continues, there is going to be little incentive for US citizens to go to college, putting themselves into debt for no reason other than to disappoint themselves after graduating with honors.

In my company there are a lot of smart and skilled non-US citizens that apply for work. On average they are much more motivated than american workers, who believe they are entitled to benefits from day one. We nevertheless hire mostly people who were born in US, since it is extremely difficult to hire a non US person and get them a proper work authorization.

I personally know hundreds of extremely smart foreign students, who work hard at US schools by getting bachelors, masters phd degrees from US schools and excelling there, who cannot find employment in the US, since most employers know that the work authization visas take a lot of time to process and some of them are even given to workers in a lotter system with a 50% success rate.
Despite the fact that foreign students typically pay out of state tuition, US resources are still spend on foreign students studying in the US. However as most of them cannot find a way to stay legaly in the US ( bc the system is screwed and most citizens believe in the lucky sperm syndrome) they leave for their own countries and make their “american dream” there.

It’s no surprise that after 9/11 when the US enforced tighter border patrols and decreased the amount of visas for skilled workers, many of the so called emerging economies experienced a boom in their economies. The reason is that the skilled workers came back to their native countries.

If the US really wants to excel, then a more open immigration policy should be started. If not, then in 50 years the US will most probably become a third world country.